The main appeal of the Chrome-powered notebooks to this point has been their super low price, but Google's brand new touchscreen Chromebook Pixel laptop starts at $1,299, a full $100 more than a 13-inch MacBook Air. The Chromebooks have been praised as a lot of computer for the price — Samsung's model costs $250; the Acer one is $200. That made sense for a computer that operated completely in the cloud, $1,200—even if it comes with a "drop-dead gorgeous" 2,560 by 1,700 resolution touchscreen and 4GB of RAM—does not.
A tough sell: "It’s a lofty goal, considering that the Chromebook doesn’t have some of the power and graphics capabilities of the MacBook, and only runs Web-based apps, which aren’t as robust as native desktop apps. Factor in the high price, and it might be a tough sell." — AllThingsD
A tough sell: "It looks like a solid laptop, but it's definitely being sold as a high-end offering. The Wi-Fi-only version will set you back $1,299, and the LTE version $1,499. Chromebooks may have a certain appeal, but it could be a tough sell when they're the same price as more capable laptops from companies like Apple and Toshiba." — NBC News
A hard sell: "Like we wrote in the beginning, the Chromebook Pixel is clearly a premium laptop, but that's also an incredibly steep price for a device that primarily runs just the web and web applications on a relatively new OS... particularly when it also has a screen with an unfamiliar resolution and aspect ratio that developers will need to target. When you can get a similarly premium laptop that does far more in the 13-inch MacBook Pro with Retina Display for $1,499, it could be a hard sell." — The Verge
It's expensive: "Google just announced its first premium Chromebook, the Chromebook Pixel. It's gorgeous. Unfortunately, it's so expensive that I can't think of a single person who should get one." — The Wirecutter
WAY TOO EXPENSIVE: "The thing costs $1,300 (or $1,450 plus a data plan if you want LTE), which is a lot of money. It's enough money to buy a solid Windows 8 system or a very nice MacBook Air. It's just $50 short of enough to buy a MacBook Pro that has a similarly retina display. The nice thing about these other options is that they're real computers, as opposed to the Pixel, which is a ripoff." — Gizmodo
Hefty price. — CNET
No value proposition: "Just like Google’s ill-fated Nexus Q, the Chromebook Pixel seems to be a beautiful piece of hardware built with nobody in mind. I can’t imagine any consumer would prefer an expensive laptop with limited capabilities over a shiny new MacBook Air, or buying a cheaper Windows 8 Ultrabook and having money left over for a tablet. There’s no value proposition with the Chromebook Pixel; it’s just a severely limited machine with a baffling — VentureBeat
You get the picture. But, there are some people who might see this as a deal. Google offers a terabyte of cloud storage for 3 years, which The New York Times's Claire Cain Miller pegs as an $1800 value. Google also sells an LTE connected one for $1,499. For you power cloud users out there who this might appeal to the schmancy laptop goes on sale today.
This article is from the archive of our partner The Wire.
We want to hear what you think about this article. Submit a letter to the editor or write to firstname.lastname@example.org.