There's a little bit of new information and a lot of new misinformation about Facebook's super, top-secret phone project — her name is "Buffy." On Monday afternoon, AllThingsD's Liz Gannes and Ina Fried published "the first in a series of posts this week about the Facebook phone," revealing not only the headline-ready code name for the project but also a recently inked partnership between Facebook and HTC. (Samsung is waiting in the wings as a "potential hardware partner.") Bloggers went nuts over the news, rushing to report on Facebook's increasingly Mongolian tendency to charge into already claimed territory and set their competitors' huts on fire. One even went with the headline, "Mark Zuckerberg Wants to Control Your Phone."
Then came MG "No Fun Police" Siegler with a sobering asterisked but journalistically rigorious debunker post with quite the opposite kind of headline, "Facebook Not Building a Phone*." Siegler correctly asserts that's he and Dan Frommer have been reporting on the Facebook phone project for over a year, and while AllThingsD has some new information (namely the bit about the name and the hardware partners), they're also encouraging some false assumptions. So, how do we to separate the rumors from the confirmable reports? Let's make a list.