Last week, as part of a soon-to-be-revived Tech Update Fiesta series, I mentioned that the Google Nexus One had held up very well in all of its "smartphone" features. Navigation, entertainment, email, web browsing, photography, telekinesis, etc. But when asked how it was at the "dumbphone" basics of making and receiving calls, I said that it was only so-so. I added that I couldn't be sure whether the problem was the phone itself, the specific carrier I was using (T-Mobile), or the overall shoddiness of US mobile phone coverage, compared with most other countries'.
Two readers respond to say that it's probably not the phone: more likely either the national grid or the specific carrier. First, the argument that it's T-Mobile's fault:
I hear all the stories about how crappy iPhone service is through AT&T, and now your post about the problems with the Nexus and T-Mobile. Just wanted to say that I can't remember the last time I had a dropped call on Verizon.
Have to admit that praising a phone company makes me shudder. My usual take on them is about the same as James Coburn's in The President's Analyst. Or Lily Tomlin's.
Now, the argument that it's America's fault. Or, more precisely, that the U.S. is in a quality race with Indonesia on this score:
Further corroboration on how perception of the Nexus' call quality really depends on network quality: I've been using the phone in Indonesia for a month, where phone coverage is dismal across the board, and have gotten disconnected even in the middle of the CBD area. Data coverage often drops from 3G to E or even G (!!) and oftentimes stalls out. Sometimes the signal is strong but it looks like too many customers try accessing the Internet at the same time and the network could not route all the requests through!
As part of my move to Germany, though, I am in Singapore yesterday and today, and lo and behold, the phone works just well. Never dropped more than 1 bar even when underground in the MRT (subway). I wonder how many other cities boast the same facilities for cell phone users -- I believe you mentioned the same is true of the Beijing subway? [Yes -- in elevators and coal mines too.]
I'll soon -- couple of weeks -- be able to verify if that holds in Nuremberg, Germany too.
We want to hear what you think about this article. Submit a letter to the editor or write to email@example.com.