He offered no apology, no admission of error, and no explanation. Mic’s Anthony Smith traced the image back to 8chan’s /pol/ message board, an internet haven for the alt-right, and from there to a Twitter account that regularly posts overtly racist and anti-Semitic images. The Clinton campaign quickly pounced. “Donald Trump’s use of a blatantly anti-Semitic image from racist websites to promote his campaign would be disturbing enough, but the fact that it’s part of a pattern should give voters major cause for concern,” it said in a statement.
By Sunday night, the Trump campaign apparently felt compelled to respond, issuing twinned statements from Trump and his campaign’s social-media director, Dan Scavino. “The social media graphic used this weekend was not created by the campaign nor was it sourced from an anti-Semitic site,” Scavino said. “It was lifted from an anti-Hillary Twitter user where countless images appear.” He explained that he’d seen the image not as a Star of David, but as a law-enforcement logo. “The sheriff’s badge—which is available under Microsoft’s ‘shapes’—fit with the theme of corrupt Hillary, and that is why I selected it.” And Scavino concluded, “As the social-media director for the campaign, I would never offend anyone and therefore chose to remove the image.”
It’s a minor classic of its genre. There’s the arms-length distancing from the problem. The introduction of irrelevant information—Sheriffs! Microsoft!—to cloud the issue. And the concluding sorry-if-you-were-offended half apology.
But if Scavino was playing the usual game of crisis communications, Trump was working from an entirely different rulebook:
These false attacks by Hillary Clinton trying to link the Star of David with a basic star, often used by sheriffs who deal with criminals and criminal behavior, showing an inscription that says “Crooked Hillary is the most corrupt candidate ever” with anti-Semitism is ridiculous.
He showed no concern with having given offense. He made no acknowledgment of the image’s actual origins. And he certainly didn’t apologize
It’s wholly plausible that Trump didn’t give the star a second thought before he sent the tweet, that he saw it as a “basic star” or a sheriff’s badge. Trump has a genius for repurposing images and slogans, drawing them from an eclectic array of sources. Ronald Reagan urged, “Let’s make America great again!” America First has been a slogan used by politicians from Woodrow Wilson to William Randolph Hearst. It’s not always clear that Trump knows, or cares, about their origins.
But in this case, the star was not, in fact, a sheriff’s badge. In the 1980 Canadian drama The Lucky Star, the hero, a Dutch teenager named David Goldberg, pretends that the six-pointed yellow star the Nazis have ordered him to wear is actually a sheriff’s badge. It was an escapist fantasy, a way of divorcing himself from the ugliness of his reality, and denying the actual meaning of the symbol. Until this weekend, it may have been the only time anyone else proved unable to distinguish between the two hexagrams.
