The emphasis on perception is a marked change from some previous House GOP investigations of the Obama administration, including probes into Fast and Furious and Solyndra, which were seen in some circles as political fishing expeditions. Many Republicans took note when House Speaker John Boehner announced last May that the Benghazi panel would be headed by Gowdy, not then-House Oversight Chairman Darrell Issa—the author of those more controversial probes.
"They have to be careful not to make it look too nakedly partisan, and more specifically, not exclusively built around the prospects of Hillary Clinton winning the White House in 2016, even though everyone in this town knows that that's true," said Thomas Schaller, a political science professor at the University of Maryland, Baltimore County.
To that point, last week Gowdy sent a letter to Clinton's attorney asking for her private email server to be turned over to the State Department's inspector general or another "neutral, detached, and independent arbiter." Gowdy didn't, however, ask for it to be sent over to the House panel.
Schaller's recent book, The Stronghold: How Republicans Captured Congress but Surrendered the White House, argues that the increasingly powerful House wing of the GOP has hobbled the party's White House prospects in recent decades. But in this case, Schaller believes the House panel is poised to help the party's 2016 prospects.
(RELATED: Clinton's Rough Road Ahead)
"This might be the one case where, if it is done right and it is done successfully, I suppose it could actually help the presidential wing of the party because it does look like Hillary Clinton was damaged by this revelation," he said of the discoveries about Clinton's email practices.
GOP strategist Rick Wilson framed it this way in Politico: "Let's try something new: maintain message discipline, hold focus and keep an eye on a bigger objective than your daily press release, social media hits or email fundraising drops."
David Marin, a former top GOP aide on the House Oversight and Government Reform Committee and a veteran of congressional investigations, says the Select Committee has proceeded with integrity.
"I think they have proceeded exactly as I would have wanted to proceed if I were working for this committee. They are quietly, diligently doing their work. You haven't seen leaks from this committee in terms of documents, you haven't see any show hearings," Marin said.
"I think at the end of the day, this committee will be judged on the quality of its report, on the report's objectivity and utility, on whether the facts presented match the conclusions the committee reaches. Everything else is just theater and noise, and I do have a strong sense that Mr. Gowdy understands this," said Marin, who is now with the Podesta Group, a prominent lobbying and PR firm.