Two days ago I mentioned Newton Minow's presentation at the National Press Club on the 50th anniversary of his own "vast wasteland" speech, as JFK's newly appointed young chairman of the Federal Communications Commission.
Yesterday a note arrived from Ray Boomhower, senior editor with the Indiana Historical Society Press in Indianapolis. He writes:
>>Thanks for the item on the Newton Minow talk commemorating the 50th anniversary of his "vast wasteland" speech. I wanted to put a plug in for the author of the speech, Indiana journalist and writer John Bartlow Martin [right]. A former newspaper reporter and one of the country's leading freelance writers in the 1950s and 1960s, Martin, who worked on the presidential campaigns of Adlai Stevenson and John F. Kennedy, had begun work on a series on television for the Saturday Evening Post. As he notes in his autobiography, It Seems Like Only Yesterday, he began the series by describing a day watching television for twenty straight hours, concluding that it had presented "a vast wasteland of junk."
In writing Minow's speech, Martin said he suggested he say to the National Association of Broadcasters: "I invite you to sit down in front of your television set when your station goes on the air . . . and keep your eyes glued to the set until the station goes off. I can assure you that you will observe a vast wasteland of junk." Martin goes on to note that in editing the speech, Minow "had the wit to cut 'of junk.'"
Of course, as a speechwriter yourself, you know, as Martin did, that even though he originated the "vast wasteland" phrase, it took nothing away from Minow, who, as Martin stated, also had the "courage to throw it [the phrase] in the teeth of the broadcasters and thus show the public the need for reform."<<
I sent this note to Newton Minow -- after all, he is an Atlantic author -- asking him if the account was correct. He wrote back just now:
>>Yes it is accurate.
I had the help of four drafts from different writers, but the best one by far was from my dear friend John Bartlow Martin who volunteered to help me.
John and I had worked together for years on Adlai Stevenson's campaigns. John's draft included :" vast wasteland of junk" and I deleted "of junk." Other parts of John's draft were also used -- some parts came from other writers and some from me.<<
I had read about Martin as a speechwriter for Adlai Stevenson and knew his work as a journalist, but I had forgotten his connection to this speech. At the Press Club event this week, Minow did mention the crucial elision that turned "vast wasteland of junk" into "vast wasteland." And as Boomhower correctly notes, the ultimate blame -- or credit -- for a political speech always belongs to the public figure who gave it, not the staff speechwriter who may have cranked it out. It's the public figure who chooses the writers, instructs them directly or indirectly, and finally decides what to use. So Minow rightly deserves lasting association with this speech and its turns of phrase; and it's also nice to know of Martin's role.
We want to hear what you think about this article. Submit a letter to the editor or write to firstname.lastname@example.org.