I'm not sure I buy the controversy -- via BloggingStocks and Clusterstock -- over Tim Geithner being named one of People Magazine's Most Beautiful People. The case against Geithner seems to be (1) His brother is an executive at People Magazine, so there's a potential conflict of interest, and (2) Geithner is not beautiful.


But most American magazines have a strict business/editorial divide, and it would be somewhat surprising if the business side of the publication were making a hamfisted attempt to meddle with editorial decisionmaking over something like this. (Important though it no doubt seems.) And while I'm not really in a position judge the merits of point #2, it does seem to me that previous Most Beautiful People have been given the honor based on something other than beauty narrowly construed.

We want to hear what you think about this article. Submit a letter to the editor or write to letters@theatlantic.com.