.... which makes it worthy of a post. You can bet that a big McCain talking point in the fall will be almost exactly as phrased below by Juan Williams. Obamaniacs will dismiss it out of hand, but the substance is not dismissable out of hand.



** The usual caveat: just because the argument isn't dismissable doesn't mean that it's valid; it does mean that Obama supporters can't expect it to be dismissed without a sustained argument. What is is not what ought to be, or what's thought to be. I feel compelled to include this caveat because so many readers seem to be confused whenever they're presented with an argument against Obama that isn't automatically and immediately rebutted or dismissed out of hand. Most American voters are not Obamaniacs. Yet.

We want to hear what you think about this article. Submit a letter to the editor or write to letters@theatlantic.com.