{"article":{"__typename":"BlogArticle","id":"BlogArticle:55740","categories":[],"content":[{"__typename":"ArticleParagraphContent","subtype":null,"idAttr":"","innerHtml":"... I should note that the design of this last-ditch McCain ad - which actually uses the word \"welfare,\" as opposed to just talking about \"spreading the wealth,\" a distinction that makes a difference - makes John Judis's \"race and Joe the Plumber\" argument seem at least slightly more tethered to plausibility:"},{"__typename":"ArticleLegacyHtml","tagName":"P","idAttr":"","className":"","style":"","innerHtml":"

"}],"editorialProject":null,"primaryCategory":{"__typename":"Channel","displayName":"Personal","url":"https://www.theatlantic.com/personal/","slug":"personal"},"reviews":[],"embeds":[],"authors":[{"id":"Author:16","displayName":"Ross Douthat","url":"https://www.theatlantic.com/author/ross-douthat/","biography":{"default":"Ross Douthat is a former contributing editor at The Atlantic.","__typename":"Biography"},"socialMedia":[],"__typename":"Author","slug":"ross-douthat"}],"preview":null,"layout":"standard","secondaryByline":"","dek":"","url":"https://www.theatlantic.com/personal/archive/2008/10/in-fairness/55740/","title":"In Fairness ... ","seoTitle":"In Fairness ... ","dateModified":"2008-10-30T13:24:45Z","datePublished":"2008-10-30T13:09:47Z","hasMeter":true,"primaryChannel":{"displayName":"Personal","__typename":"Channel","slug":"personal"},"shareImage1x1":null,"shareImage16x9":null,"shareImage4x3":null,"shareImageDefault":null,"shareImageSquareDefault":null,"shareImageLeadArt":null,"shareDek":"","shareText":null,"shareTitle":"In Fairness ... ","editorsNote":null,"leadArt":null,"fbiaUrl":"https://www.theatlantic.com/facebook-instant/article/55740/","canonicalUrl":"https://www.theatlantic.com/personal/archive/2008/10/in-fairness/55740/","syndication":"ALL","shareImage2x1":null,"shareImageSmall":null,"channels":[{"slug":"personal","__typename":"Channel"}],"watsonInfo":{"keywords":["last-ditch McCain ad","John Judis"],"__typename":"WatsonInfo"},"slug":"in-fairness","grapeshot":{"segments":["gv_safe","an_apple_negative","neg_apple_1","ap_sustainableinvesting","gs_home_interiors","gb_safe","pos_alcohol","pos_chasemarriott","pos_citibank","pos_creditcard","pos_disasters","pos_diseases","pos_disney_fxfargo","pos_ey","pos_facebook_safety","pos_hermes","pos_ibm","pos_jpmc","pos_mastercard","pos_mobkoi","pos_septembereleven","pos_toyota_fy23","neg_equitable","an_bankofamerica_negative","an_facebook_safe","an_jpmc_safe","an_ms_safe","an_volvo_safe","ap_alfaromeo_safe","ap_bankofamerica_safe","ap_citi_banking_safe","ap_citi_hurricanes","ap_citi_injury","ap_citi_naacp_safe","ap_citi_sex_safe","ap_citi_transportation_safe","ap_facebook_infeed_safe","ap_facebook_safe","ap_fidelity_safe","ap_gwp","ap_jpmc_safe","ap_ms_safe","ap_netflix_israeli_safe","ap_texas_shooting_safe","ap_volvo_safe","general_safe_gv","gs_home","coronavirus","neg_citibank"],"__typename":"Grapeshot"},"advertisingInfo":{"disableHouseAd":false,"__typename":"AdvertisingInfo"}}}

Sections

The Print Edition