Reporter's Notebook

Should All Drugs Be Decriminalized?
Show Description +

Spurred by comments from Richard Branson at The Atlantic’s Summit on Mental Health and Addiction, readers grapple with the question of whether all drugs, including heroin, should be decriminalized. Join the debate via, especially if you have a personal connection with addiction.

Show None Newer Notes

Why Shouldn't We Follow the Path of Portugal?

When it comes to the war on drugs, reader Michel contrasts the success in Portugal with the devastation in Mexico:

Christopher Ingraham / Washington Post

Your reader Ethan wrote: “Even small-government conservatives like myself believe in government intervention when critical for safety, and it’s not challenging to argue that the ‘hard’ drugs aren’t safe under any circumstances.” And there you have much of what’s wrong with American democracy. “Yes, I see the evidence, but I just don’t care, because my common sense tells me something different.”

The use of hard drugs in Portugal has gone down, not up. Drug-related deaths in Portugal have gone down, not up. Drug-related HIV infections in Portugal have gone down, not up. Is that not the definition of “safer”?

A bit of Googling indicates the picture on drug-related crime (robberies, etc.) is murky, what with the collapse of the Portuguese economy since drug legalization. But there doesn’t seem to be any solid evidence that drug-related crime has gone up.

Not to mention—OK, I’m gonna mention it—that the drug-cartel wars in Mexico [between the years 2006 and 2012 saw an estimated total number of homicides reach as high as 125,000], not including an estimated 25,000 missing. That also doesn’t include the drug-gang wars in other countries of Central and South America. Are these people, and their friends and families, not human beings? Does their suffering count for nothing?

Excuse me, I think I need a drink.

On that note, another reader asks, “What about alcohol and tobacco?”

I believe that those two drugs are far more harmful and addictive than all of the other illegal drugs out there. The ravages of alcohol and tobacco are well known, yet they are still socially acceptable. So where do we draw the line?

I just feel that no matter how we slice it, people will continue to use drugs. Why not bring it all out into the light?

That’s the conclusion that reader Thomas approaches in his comprehensive case for “decriminalizing or legalizing all drugs”:

Not only has the global War On Drugs been an exorbitant waste of money, it has fueled the rise of mass incarceration, broken families and communities, and the rise of murderous drug cartels. Furthermore, has it curbed drug consumption in the United States or abroad? No.

If drugs are legalized or remain illegal, the fact of the matter is, people will continue to do them. I think that the focus must be more on harm reduction and rehabilitation. We hear about the “last stop” for most addicts—overdose and death. What doesn’t get much of the attention is the multitude of other problems associated with drug use, such as the spread of HIV and hepatitis infections, as well as the hospitalizations and surgeries (paid for by taxpayers) due to abscesses from sharing dirty needles. Addicts clog up emergency rooms because they’re looking for a fix, looking to get off the street, or they’re suffering from an infection. The healthcare system is not equipped to treat these patients, so they’re patched up and shipped back to the streets without any treatment for their underlying problem with addiction.

That’s how this reader describes his past:

I have been sober—free from drugs and alcohol—for almost nine years. Before I started my journey out of addiction, my life revolved around alcohol, cocaine, MDMA, and prescription painkillers. Not a day goes by that I don’t feel extreme gratitude for where I am now. I know that I am lucky to have found a way out, since most addicts don’t; they end up in prison or in a cemetery.

My experience has really shaped my views on public policy surrounding drugs and addiction. I believe that our current views and policy surrounding illegal drugs is not only ineffective, it perpetuates the very problem it aims to solve.

First, while I was in the trenches with my addiction, I lived in fear. I was afraid of what people thought of me, afraid of being lonely and inadequate; my life was run by fear. Even so, I was never afraid that I was breaking the law. I didn’t think twice about using illegal drugs and I didn’t think twice about breaking the law to continue using them.

Furthermore, I didn’t get sober because I was afraid. I was arrested numerous times, I was berated by a judge in front of a courtroom full of people, I developed serious financial problems and health problems … and yet I still continued to use drugs and alcohol. I didn’t fear the consequences, the loss of family and friends, or the threat of jail.