Cut to the next morning. The next thing she remembers, Jane Doe said, is waking up "embarrassed, scared, not sure what to think," under a blanket in an unfamiliar place surrounded by three boys. She said it was "really scary." She got up to get dressed, but no one could find her phone or her underwear. Two of her friends picked her up, and after a short trip to drop off the two defendants, they started yelling at her over what they were hearing about the night before. She didn't remember anything they were yelling at her for. Doe repeatedly said she felt "freaked out and embarrassed" for blacking out on the events of the evening.
After getting dropped off at her mom's house, she immediately admitted to her mother that she didn't remember anything and that she couldn't find her shoes or phone. Getting in trouble was "the last thing on my mind," she said. Eventually, she started to hear about what was circling on social media. At this point in the testimony, Doe started crying again after being shown a photo in the courtroom, one she had already seen. She said the carpet in the photo matched the basement room she woke up in.
The girl said she thought she knew everything she drank that night, and had never blacked out before. Only after insistence from a number of immediate and extended family members did she go to the hospital to get checked out. There, two days after the party, doctors told her a rape kit wouldn't show anything because of the amount of time between the assault and the hospital visit. She was reluctant to tell the doctor the names of the boys involved; she didn't want to get involved in any of the drama that would ensue. (She did absolve Charlie Keenan, the son of the former prosecutor who was named in the original report, from doing anything that night.) But that didn't stop of the defendants from texting her repeatedly over the few days after party, frantically the morning after, and "freaking out," she says, asking whether or not she was going to tell the police.
Eventually her parents reported the alleged assault to the police. She sent a text message to one of the defendants, apparently Mays, insisting that she didn't want to go to the cops: "We know you didn't rape me," it said. The girl went on to say that she had not been aware at the time that digital penetration was also considered rape.
The prosecution showed a series of text messages to the courtroom sent between Jane Doe and Mays and Richmond in the following days. She alleged that one of the defendants, apparently Mays, said that the the football team's coach, who will take the stand at the trial as well, called his house and told them they raped her, and the defendant asked her to "tell her dad the truth." She said social media was telling a different story. "This is the most pointless thing. I am gonna get in trouble for nothing," he allegedly texted her. "You know what happened, there's no video, so nothing happened," another text from Mays read. The defendants told her she had been a hassle, and that they "took care of her." But when she saw the video of Steubenville High athlete Michael Nodianos making fun of her, she thought differently: "I knew everyone telling me that they were taking care of me, that that was not true," she said. One of the defendants, apparently Mays, also admitted, in a text message, to taking a picture of his bodily fluids on her after they were done doing whatever they allegedly did:
The girl told the court she believed she was drugged, a charge that has been challenged by the very friends — now former friends — who testified against her for the defense. Earlier on Saturday, an expert for the defense said the victim's blood alcohol content would have been an estimated .18 or .25 and that the girl should have been able to voluntarily make her own decisions, even if she didn't remember them. Her testimony focused primarily on whether the girl was "black out drunk," or "passed out drunk," with the expert ruling for the former. But then this happened:
On cross-examination, prosecutor Marianne Hemmeter showed Fromme a picture of the teen girl apparently passed out and being carried by the defendants. Fromme said she had not seen the picture. Fromme also had not seen pictures of the girl laying naked on a couch and on the floor of a basement.
That photo — an Instagram image that has come to stand for the complex social-media trial that proceeded the actual one — has been seen my millions of people. And still the defense is relying on a strategy concerning levels of drunkenness to prove consent. But now Jane Doe has told her story for the prosecution, as she does and does not remember it. Judge Thomas Lipps is expected, after another long day of emotional testimony from the football coach and more, to announce a verdict on Sunday.