It's the best of holidays: summer, freedom, hot dogs, Americana. Three patriotic thoughts on this day.
1) First, the general idea from our neighborhood parade this morning, in DC:
How do I and my neighbors, as residents of America's capital of Washington, resemble my former neighbors in China's capital of Beijing?
The answer, of course, is that all of us pay taxes to our respective national governments, but none of us has any voting representation in our country's respective legislatures. The difference is that Beijingers share that problem with everyone else in China, while DC residents are unique among Americans.
What is crazy about DC's "taxation without representation" status, as immortalized on DC license plates, is that no one could possibly justify its continuation in any rational way. (Are DC residents already "too influential," and therefore don't need to be represented? For one thing, the vast majority of them aren't. And for another, we don't use that excuse to deny the franchise to Manhattan, Palo Alto, Cambridge, McLean, Bethesda, or other centers of people who on average have plenty of influence anyway.) But this anachronism affects fewer than a million people, and no one else cares. Just a thought for the day.
2) On a more positive note, it's a day to remember underappreciated Americans who have made a big difference. I've just finished reading a book about one of them: the late John Moss, who from the early 1950s through the late 1970s was a Congressman from California's Central Valley. It is mainly because of Moss that we now have a Freedom of Information Act, a Consumer Product Safety Commission, various financial-reform bodies, and a host of other protections that would not have a prayer of getting through the Congress if they were introduced now.
Moss's longtime aide and associate, Michael Lemov, has written a new biography of him, People's Warrior, that is startling mainly in recalling an era in which politicians actually thought (gasp!) that they could agree on significant reforms and get them passed in relatively short order. It's only a generation ago, though it seems as distant as the time of Upton Sinclair and Lincoln Steffens, and Lemov's book conveys what it was like. As does this touchingly earnest foreword by Ralph Nader, who as a young "consumer advocate" was one of Moss's allies:
>>For young people today, beset with cynicism about Congress or simply "turned off" from politics, this book is an awakening antidote. It reminds that, not so long ago, Congress did significant things for the people of this country. Our First Branch enacted major civil rights legislation and Medicare/Medicaid in a two-year period. It enacted the comprehensive auto and highway safety laws just nine months after the publication of my book Unsafe at Any Speed. These great lifesaving laws were signed by President Lyndon Johnson in 1966. Mr. Moss had an important role in their enactment.The book is worth reading and reflecting upon. UPDATE: The Atlantic's Joshua Green, who was co-author with Rep. Henry Waxman of a book about how Congress really works, tells me that Waxman viewed Moss as a mentor, especially about effective Congressional oversight of agencies and businesses. Waxman told Green that he learned about "the 'public spectacle' aspect of using hearings to bring pressure and influence debate--from watching Moss."
Within three years--from 1970 through 1972--groundbreaking product safety and air and water pollution laws were enacted and given to newly formed agencies to implement. It is important for young people today, who see procrastination, cowardliness, evasions, corporate-indentured stagnation, and arrogance running through members of Congress like an epidemic, to read about a different time when many more legislators knew why they were sent to Washington by the voters back home.<<
3) After the jump, an embedded video of Timothy Geithner, Treasury Secretary, being interviewed a few weeks ago by Mike Allen of Politico. The parts worth listening to are the first minute or so of introduction -- and then Geithner's comments starting at about time 39:00, after Allen has asked Geithner whether he's going to be the first Treasury Secretary in history to preside over a default in US obligations.
"Absolutely not," Geithner says. That is when he pulls a copy of the Constitution out of his pocket and reads the section of the 14th Amendment that says, "The validity of the public debt of the United States, authorized by law, including debts incurred for payment of pensions and bounties for services in suppressing insurrection or rebellion, shall not be questioned." Emphasis very much added -- by him. He goes on to say that the leaders in Congress understand that the country cannot default on its debts. But:
"There are some people who are pretending not to understand this, or think there is leverage for them as a negotiating position. I don't understand it as a negotiating position. Really, think about it... As a negotiating strategy you're saying, If you don't do things my way, I'm going to force the United States into default and not pay the legacy of bills accumulated by my predecessors in Congress? It's not a credible negotiating strategy. And it's not going to happen."
For more, see Ryan Grim's reporting on Geithner's "it's not going to happen" statements, plus the video after the jump.
4) Here's a bonus fourth patriotic thought! It's a tip to the site Seeing Red in China, where an American who has lived and worked in China for the past four years reflects on what the experience has taught him about his homeland, on Independence Day.
Finally, if you were feeling as if you wanted one more topical reminder of the DC plight, here's the ACLU/DC Statehood brass band at the parade.*
And, what the hell, here are two of the three separate troupes of elaborately costumed Bolivian residents of the DC area who danced their way along the multi-mile parade route. It's a great country.
We want to hear what you think about this article. Submit a letter to the editor or write to firstname.lastname@example.org.