This article is from the archive of our partner .

Dr. Lazar Greenfield might want to reconsider urging critics of his retracted editorial on the purported mood-elevating qualities of semen to read the original Surgery News piece "in the spirit in which it was intended" before lambasting him. Commenter and self-described "science nerd" WAknight suggests a reexamination will only raise more questions. He explains:

Maybe I'm a science nerd. But something pretty bad here is the idea that an editorial in a trade journal would neglect to examine other possible causes for the effect. Like say, being in a long-term relationship (which is when people are most likely to have unprotected sex) rather than being single or having more casual sexual encounters (shorter-term relationships, one-night stands, whatever). Not to say that 'commitment' is the sure road to happiness or that people can't be perfectly happy being celibate or sleeping around, but I seem to recall happiness surveys generally showing that people in long-term romantic relationships (marriage or long-term dating) tended to be happiest.

Thanks for reading, everyone. And be sure to check out Open Wire, where you can share links, feedback, and opinions on the stories you think we should be covering.

This article is from the archive of our partner The Wire.

We want to hear what you think about this article. Submit a letter to the editor or write to letters@theatlantic.com.