European Refugee Crisis: A 'Systematic' Violation of Human Rights

The UN human-rights commissioner has accused the Czech Republic of a systematic violation of the human rights of migrants and refugees in order to deter them from coming to the country.

Measures cited by Zeid Ra’ad Al Hussein include strip-searching migrants and refugees in order to confiscate money that is then used to pay for their detention, which can last up to 90 days.

“According to credible reports from various sources, the violations of the human rights of migrants are neither isolated nor coincidental, but systematic: They appear to be an integral part of a policy by the Czech Government designed to deter migrants and refugees from entering the country or staying there,” Zeid said in a statement issued in Geneva.

Many migrants and refugees are fleeing the civil war in Syria and unrest elsewhere, and are making their way to safety in Europe. Their preferred destination is Germany, which has opened its doors to those fleeing the conflict in Syria. But to get there, the migrants and refugees must first traverse Central European states, many of which have adopted policies, including border closures, that restrict the new arrivals.

In his statement, Zeid noted these restrictions, and added, “the Czech Republic is unique in routinely subjecting these migrants and refugees to detention for 40 days, and reportedly sometimes even longer—up to 90 days—in conditions which have been described as degrading.”

He also expressed concern about the Czech detention facilities where the migrants and refugees are being held, particularly Bìlá-Jezovqá—a facility that Robert Pelikán, the Czech justice minister, said was “worse than a prison.” Pelikán has also criticized the detention of the migrants and refugees for up to 90 days.

Zeid noted those migrants and refugees who have challenged their detention in court have prevailed, but most aren’t in a position to go to court either because they lack information about their right to free legal aid or because civil-society groups that work with them are given restricted access at some detention facilities.

The center-left Czech government’s practices have been criticized by its own ombudsman, Anna Šabatová, who in a report this month noted that the treatment of children at the detention centers violated the Convention on the Rights of the Child.

Zeid’s statement also said refugees and migrants were strip-searched by the authorities looking to confiscate money in order to pay the approximately $10 per day each person is charged for his or her detention. It said there were no clear legal grounds for such a step.

“The fact that people are being forced to pay for their own detention is particularly reprehensible,” Zeid said.

The UN commissioner for human rights also criticized President Miloš Zeman’s remarks about Muslims and the “Against Immigration” public petition started by Václav Klaus, the former Czech president.

Zeman has said the newcomers will impose Shariah law in the Czech Republic. Last week, he was quoted as saying: “We will lose women’s beauty because they will be covered head to toe in burqas, with only a fabric net over the face.”

His spokesman rejected Zeid’s criticism, telling Reuters: “The president has long warned of the threat of Islamic fundamentalism. He stands by his opinion and he will not change it under pressure from abroad.”

About the Author

Krishnadev Calamur is a senior editor at The Atlantic, where he oversees news coverage. He is a former editor and reporter at NPR and the author of Murder in Mumbai.

Twitter

A new study finds that believing society is fair can lead disadvantaged adolescents to act out and engage in risky behavior.

Brighton Park is a predominantly Latino community on the southwest side of Chicago. It’s a neighborhood threatened by poverty, gang violence, ICE raids, and isolation—in a city where income, race, and zip code can determine access to jobs, schools, healthy food, and essential services. It is against this backdrop that the Chicago teacher Xian Franzinger Barrett arrived at the neighborhood’s elementary school in 2014.

Recognizing the vast economic and racial inequalities his students faced, he chose what some might consider a radical approach for his writing and social-studies classes, weaving in concepts such as racism, classism, oppression, and prejudice. Barrett said it was vital to reject the oft-perpetuated narrative that society is fair and equal to address students’ questions and concerns about their current conditions. And Brighton Elementary’s seventh- and eighth-graders quickly put the lessons to work—confronting the school board over inequitable funding, fighting to install a playground, and creating a classroom library focused on black and Latino authors.