a sign of just how little NATO and the rebels coordinate their war
against Qaddafi, Libyan fighters must rely on a single air traffic
control tower to know what the Western powers are doing
A Libyan rebel stands guard at Benghazi International Airport. Suhaib Salem / Reuters
BENGHAZI, Libya -- Every time a NATO jet comes within 240 miles of the Libyan rebel stronghold of Benghazi, a group of men in a large smoke-filled room on the edge of the city gather around a screen to watch it happen in real time. They just don't know what they're actually seeing until it's reported later in the media.
Benghazi's civil airport, though closed for business, is still operating its aviation radar, picking up everything above 1,000 feet that comes into its range. But because of a United Nations-imposed no-fly zone over Libya, all of the traffic it detects is military. With no commercial airliners taking off or landing at the Benghazi airport, the air traffic controllers report to work only to watch their country's civil war rendered in blocky, flickering pixels, as if it were a video game from the early 1980s.
"During the last two weeks, we've seen a lot of aircraft, but not striking," said one controller who, like everyone else in the tower, refused to be identified because my visit in mid-April was not authorized by the transitional government. They were afraid of losing their jobs. "Now [the rate of airstrikes] is getting better. We just sit here and watch."
Of course, the men are just guessing as to whether an aircraft on the screen may be attacking or simply reconnoitering the positions of troops loyal to Muammar Qaddafi and the rebel forces arrayed against them. NATO doesn't communicate with the control tower, though it could help the rebels coordinate attacks on Qaddafi's forces, and the radar displays no terrain features or live satellite view.
Instead, the monitor is filled with white diamonds silently moving across a black background. The planes fly across colored lines indicating Libya's coast and purple four-letter abbreviations of cities. Numbers indicating speed and altitude accompany the diamonds on their flight paths.
Typical aviation codes that tell controllers the type and origin of airplanes in Libya's airspace have been replaced with numbers unique to NATO. The men, civilian air traffic controllers unfamiliar with the military jets, can't tell what types of planes they're watching.
But they can guess when they might be attacking. If a plane's airspeed suddenly slows and its altitude plunges, it's probably striking something.
"Whenever an aircraft is going down to the lower level, we presume the aircraft is going to strike," said the air traffic control supervisor as he puffed on a cigarette. At another terminal, three men with Kalashnikovs, the facility's security guards, watched the screen with fascination.
Another clue that a strike may be underway is when a plane turns off its transponder, which broadcasts aviation information to the control tower. In that instance, the diamonds turn to circles, with no information about their speed or altitude.
"We presume that that has indicated the aircraft has gone down to strike," the supervisor said.
Around noon that Monday, most of the NATO traffic was over the Mediterranean, cruising at altitudes above 30,000 feet. But there were also aircraft flying lower around the besieged rebel enclave of Misurata, the government stronghold of Surte, and along the eastern front between Ajdabiya and Brega, where airstrikes took out a column of government vehicles the day before. The airstrike -- and others throughout the mid-April weekend -- aided rebels in regaining control of Ajdabiya, the critical crossroads city on the rebel frontier, which they still hold.
Like much else related to the two-month old rebellion, members of the opposition government aren't sure how to capitalize on the real-time intelligence gleaned from the civil radar. Air traffic controllers say their former military counterparts -- with whom they worked side by side in peacetime, as the airport also handles military air traffic -- sometimes use cell phones to call rebel commanders in the field to tell them when it seems an airstrike might be underway. On most days, a high-ranking member of the Transitional National Government also spends the day observing the radar.
But any link between NATO and the rebels ends there. One controller said NATO has never called or contacted the tower -- not to coordinate with rebel field units or to tell them to switch off the radar, and not to at least control access to it by outsiders, to prevent sensitive information about NATO aircraft being leaked to government forces.
In fact, the latter sensibility seemed to be reached in unison by the controllers during my visit. Increasingly uncomfortable answering detailed questions posed by a stranger, I was finally asked to provide identification and eventually, politely, to leave.
We want to hear what you think about this article. Submit a letter to the editor or write to email@example.com.