Useful ideas from David Bernstein, who makes an interesting point about the importance of J Street:
[A]s a perusal of the comments on any major liberal blog will show, and as public opinion polls also show, Israel is quickly losing support on the American liberal-left. It's vitally important that pro-Israel "progressives" have a home in which they can advocate both for Israel within the left, and for peacenik policies within the general American political and pro-Israel contexts.
That said, he has thoughts, among them this one:
During the Cold War, there were anti-Communists, and what one wag deemed "anti-anti-Communists." The anti-anti-Communists were people who purported to be against Communism, but they spent almost all their efforts denouncing the "right-wing" anti-Communists, and precious little fighting Communism. Similarly, JStreet risks claiming to be "pro-Israel," but really in practice being primarily a lobby against pro-Israel people who are further to the right, and spending precious little time battling truly anti-Israel folks on the Left. (Would that make JStreet anti-anti-anti-Israel? Or just "anti-pro-Israel"?) Most of its energy so far, from what I can tell, has been spent attacking "right-wing" Jewish groups and individuals, and even Israeli government policies, and precious little battling the extreme hostility to Israel one often finds on the progressive left.
We want to hear what you think about this article. Submit a letter to the editor or write to email@example.com.