I guess I sort of felt, I'll be honest with you, it was two pronged: On one hand [I felt] if Shakespeare didn't write the plays, what a tragedy it'd
been that this other person wasn't recognized. But even more importantly, whether Shakespeare did write the plays or didn't write the plays, we're
being taught a lot of bunk about William Shakespeare. I bristle when people teach me things and present them as facts when in fact they are not facts.
That alone was enough to make me want to make this movie.
What sold you on the notion that Shakespeare wasn't the author?
For me, you have to start off with the fact that there's no evidence he wrote the plays. … There's no first-hand documentary evidence. You start
there. Then you go to the ability to write these plays, which we all know are so amazing and beautiful and filled with so many metaphors about so many
things, like falconry and lawn bowling and tennis. … One has to make the leap that this young man from Stratford-upon-Avon, brilliant though he
may have been, would have had [to have had] one heck of an education to write these things. And yet there's no record of him having attended any
school, anywhere, ever.
So, I follow Mark Twain, who wrote a book about this issue [Is Shakespeare Dead?] and said, he, Mark Twain could never have written about the
Mississippi had he not been a Mississippi riverboat pilot. … I happen to believe that Shakespeare didn't have the life to draw from to write
about court intrigue, to write about the things I was just mentioning, the images that are filled through these plays. It just was not the life of a
What about the argument that Shakespeare could have written about nobility without being a noble?
There's no Internet in 1600. He had no library. No books. There were no public libraries. You cannot write about 16th century law accurately because
you're gifted. You can only do that because you understand 16th century law. I just don't believe the genius theory. It's different than music, where
you only have to learn a certain amount of notes and then you go [and play or compose]. It's different with writing. That's why Walt Whitman, why Henry
James, why James Joyce, why all of these writers in particular don't believe Shakespeare wrote the plays. They know what it is to write.
that the film was controversial when it was being cast, attracting ire from Judi Dench and others. What did you make of that?
I was fascinated by it, actually, that people take it so incredibly seriously. I'm sure those very same people loved the play Amadeus, which
has absolutely no basis in fact whatsoever. Or maybe they love Shakespeare in Love. Clearly Judi Dench had no problem with the fantasy that is Shakespeare in Love. It's a lovely film but there's not one millisecond that has anything to do with historical accuracy.