SurveillanceFlagWillVarner

Jack Balkin is appalled by the treatment of Bradley Manning. His view of the bigger picture:

[My view] is that Obama has played the same role with respect to the National Surveillance State that Eisenhower played with respect to the New Deal and the administrative state, and Nixon played with respect to the Great Society and the welfare state. Each President established a bi-partisan consensus and gave bi-partisan legitimation to certain features of national state building.

After the Obama presidency, opponents of a vigorous national surveillance state will be outliers in American politics; they will have no home in either major political party. Their views will be, to use one of my favorite theoretical terms, "off the wall."

(Image by Will Varner)

We want to hear what you think about this article. Submit a letter to the editor or write to letters@theatlantic.com.