by Conor Friedersdorf
Cheryl Miller has been arguing that "the repeal of Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell represents an enormous opportunity to repair the breach between the university and the military." I think she's right, and that if possible Ivy League campuses without ROTC programs should re-institute them, as she's been arguing.
Andrew Exum wonders if it is possible:
It's easy to demonize the "elite" universities for not having more ROTC programs, but the reality is that the U.S. military has been the one most responsible for divesting from ROTC programs in the northeastern United States. It's hardly the fault of Columbia University that the U.S. Army has only two ROTC programs to serve the eight million residents and 605,000 university students of New York City. And it's not the University of Chicago's fault that the entire city of Chicago has one ROTC program while the state of Alabama has ten. The U.S. military made a conscious decision to cut costs by recruiting and training officers where people were more likely to volunteer.
Miller basically concurs, and sums up as follows:
The military will have to be ready to make a number of cultural adjustments... Within its ranks, there are some who feel considerable bitterness (some of it justified, some not) toward elite schools and the largely "blue" enclaves in which they are situated; others whose otherwise healthy anti-elitism has caused them to discount the benefits of expanding ROTC's reach, and finally, those who are ambivalent about the value of a liberal arts education to the officer corps. The resulting policy has been to limit ROTC scholarships for students at elite schools, conserving costs but also ensuring limited interest among a student group military leadership considers "short-timers" and whose strengths ("sensitivity, abundant intelligence, and creativity") have been seen as inimical or irrelevant to junior officer development. (All this is recounted in depressing detail in the Army Cadet Command history.
We want to hear what you think about this article. Submit a letter to the editor or write to firstname.lastname@example.org.