A reader writes:

We don't even have to come up with a hypothetical situation as a counter-example: anyone who says, "Jews killed Jesus," is pretty much labeled as an anti-Semite, right?

Except some Romans actually did it. But point taken. Another writes:

I’m trying to imagine O’Reilly protesting the construction of a VFW hall in Oklahoma City because the people who blew up the Murrah Building were veterans.

Keep trying. I think my pro-life terrorist hypothetical works the best. And I can remember a time in Britain when some assumed all terrorists were Irish and Catholic.

We want to hear what you think about this article. Submit a letter to the editor or write to letters@theatlantic.com.