Andrew Exum calls Joshua Foust's criticism of the Afghanistan Study Group report "the most clinical and devastating take-down of a policy paper I have ever read." Josh:

[T]he best way to ensure Afghanistan does not fall into chaos is to leave the country as stable as possible. Reducing it to a Special Forces and Drone targetting range, which the group recommends, is just as unsustainable in the long run as the current counterinsurgency effort. Maintaining an active drone program to preemptively bomb any new al Qaeda camps that might spring up will be difficult if not impossible without a massive human intelligence network to support itand that HUMINT network cannot be maintained without a significant U.S. military and intelligence presence in the country (which is difficult to do if 80% of the force is withdrawn over the next 18 months, as ASG suggest).

We want to hear what you think about this article. Submit a letter to the editor or write to letters@theatlantic.com.