Justin Logan, who participated in the Afghanistan Study Group report, defends his work:

I cannot find evidence that either Foust or Exum recognizes strategic thought. Both appear to believe that they are engaging in it by picking nits with various aspects of the report’s analysis, but none of their critiques of the smaller claims does anything to knock down the report’s conclusion: that America has limited interests in Afghanistan; that those interests are actually reasonably easy to achieve; and that our current efforts there are at best wasteful and at worst counterproductive.

(Hat tip: Compass)

We want to hear what you think about this article. Submit a letter to the editor or write to letters@theatlantic.com.