by Chris Bodenner
The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals just stayed Judge Walker's ruling. Brian Devine reacts:
First, and drastically most importantly, the Court granted the stay. Consequently the thousands of couples who were waiting for the day of equality will have to wait at least a few more months until December.
Second, the Court wants this case to be resolved quickly. Appellants’ opening brief is due in just a month and the hearing will happen on December 6th. This is lightning quick for a Federal Court of Appeals, and it’s a very good sign. The Court understands that this case is important, and it doesn’t want it to linger.
Third, the Court specifically orders the Prop 8 proponents to show why this case should not be dismissed for lack of standing. Here’s a discussion of the standing issue. This is very good news for us. It shows that the Court has serious doubts about whether the Appellants have standing. Even better, the Court is expressing an opinion that its inclination is that the case should be dismissed. That being said, the panel that issued this Order (the motions panel) is not the same panel that will hear that case on the merits. The merits panel will be selected shortly before December 6th and we don’t know the three judges who will be on the merits panel. But this is a very good sign that the appeal could be dismissed on the ground of standing alone.
(Photo: Same-sex couple Kristen Orbin and Teresa Rowe embrace on August 12 in San Francisco as they wait to hear a decision on whether same-sex marriages will be allowed to resume in California. By Justin Sullivan/Getty Images.)
We want to hear what you think about this article. Submit a letter to the editor or write to email@example.com.