Manzi responds to Millman. He disagrees that a carbon tax would spur innovation:

Why would increasing [gas] prices in America work when it hasn’t for Europe? There might be some carbon price that would radically accelerate innovation across the array of uses of fossil fuels ... but it has never, to my knowledge, been imposed anywhere at scale, presumably because it would impoverish any country that tried.

We want to hear what you think about this article. Submit a letter to the editor or write to