Andrew Gelman tries to answer:

Being a moderate is worth about 2% of the vote in a congressional election: it ain’t nuthin, but it certainly is not a paramount concern for most representatives....Incumbent congressmembers almost always win reelection.  And, when they don’t, they’re often losing as part of a national swing (as in the 1994 Republican sweep or the 2006/2008 Democratic shift).  And when an incumbent does lose unexpectedly, it can be for something unrelated to their votes (remember the “check kiting scandal” of 1992?).

We want to hear what you think about this article. Submit a letter to the editor or write to letters@theatlantic.com.