Playing one of the Washington's current parlour games, Massie explains why the general shouldn't run for president in 2012:

A 2012 campaign seems exceedingly improbable. For that to happen, Afghanistan would a) have to become a disaster, b) Petraeus would have to resign, blaming Barack Obama for failing in his duty and c) the public would have to back the former Chairman of the Joint Chiefs rather than the President...I suspect many senior officers at the Pentagon would be horrified if this were to happen. It would politicise the military and place enormous strains upon the chain of command, not just now but in the future too, driving a wedge between the military and the civilian population. Even Douglas MacArthur realised he couldn't credibly run for the Presidency.

We want to hear what you think about this article. Submit a letter to the editor or write to letters@theatlantic.com.