by Patrick Appel

Julian Sanchez counters Jonah Goldberg:

We had better hope fiction isn’t a reliable guide to our moral intuitions, because with a tub of popcorn and some Milk Duds in hand, we routinely cheer thieves, thugs, and murderous sociopaths provided they’re kind to children and puppies or make a habit of mostly killing or victimizing mean people, or seem like maybe they’re sorry about that whole “lifetime of causing mayhem and suffering,” or frankly just dress stylishly and seem kind of badass.

Radley Balko piles on.

We want to hear what you think about this article. Submit a letter to the editor or write to letters@theatlantic.com.