by Patrick Appel

Massie takes on those who claim torture is justified:

If I knew that I could commit a crime - housebreaking say - and get away with it, would that give me license to commit such a crime because I really, really needed the stuff I'd steal, I had no other way of getting that stuff and I could steal it in a very efficient manner? Would the "harsh interrogation techniques" brigade think that fine and dandy?

Ambinder does the same. And Ryan Sager wants to change the terms of the debate.

We want to hear what you think about this article. Submit a letter to the editor or write to letters@theatlantic.com.