by Patrick Appel

Dale Carpenter's take on that DOJ DOMA brief from yesterday:

This new position is a gift to the gay-marriage movement, since it was not necessary to support the government's position. It will be cited by litigants in state and federal litigation, and will no doubt make its way into judicial opinions. Indeed, some state court decisions have relied very heavily on procreation and child-rearing rationales to reject SSM claims. The DOJ is helping knock out a leg from under the opposition to gay marriage....While gay-rights groups complain that the DOJ is continuing to defend the constitutionality of DOMA....and are understandably disturbed by the still-unabandoned arguments the DOJ made back in June, they should be delighted by the turn taken in this reply brief. It will serve the cause of SSM in state and especially federal courts for years to come.

We want to hear what you think about this article. Submit a letter to the editor or write to letters@theatlantic.com.