Andy McCarthy is using the Uighur uprising in China to "prove" that the Gitmo Uighurs were terrorists. Radley Balko sighs:

There was once a time when, if an ethnic minority was rising up against an oppressive communist regime, you could count on National Review to side with the rabble-rousers fighting for political freedom, not the commies. But I guess that was pre-September 11. Now it’s apparently all about siding with whoever is killing Muslims.

Actually, it's all about retaining the right to torture Muslims.

We want to hear what you think about this article. Submit a letter to the editor or write to letters@theatlantic.com.