Blogger "Laura" at HotAir thinks that she has caught me in a contradiction because I defended publishing information about prop 8 donors' - as mandated by law:

Evidently Sullivan does not expect Publius to be proud of his formerly unaccountable free speech, nor thankful for the increased opportunity for political engagement. Publishing a name and job is merciless targeting; publishing a name, job and address is just good politics.

When someone contributes money to an initiative, that donation becomes public information. Merely publishing it does not out someone's anonymity; it simply publicizes something already available to anyone who finds it. And we simply didn't see the gay hordes besieging Prop 8 homes and addresses thereafter, as so many anti-gay hysterics forecast. What the list did accomplish was show which people the marriage equality movement has yet to win over; and which people we have to work harder to convince. That's partly why this information is public in the first place - that and revealing quite how dedicated the Church of Latter Day Saints is to removing the civil rights of others who do not live up to their theology.

We want to hear what you think about this article. Submit a letter to the editor or write to