That's the firefighter case that has ignited the far right on Sotomayor. Hilzoy reads the damn thing:

[B]oth the District Court and the Second Circuit seem to me to have been applying the law in accordance with clear precedents. This is what judges are supposed to do. And anyone who thinks that this decision (made by this court) is problematic should not go on to criticize Judge Sotomayor for judicial activism, since no one who genuinely thought there was a problem with substituting one's own views about what the law ought to be for what it actually says would object to this decision.

We want to hear what you think about this article. Submit a letter to the editor or write to letters@theatlantic.com.