I'd flunk, if only out of Catholic guilt for things I haven't even done. Others also struggle:

No, I said, and began to feel the impossibility of telling truth to a polygraph machine-of ever being verified by the machine as a good guy. The thrill was gone, and I began to feel suffocated by the convoluted tubes, assaulted by endless questions that seemed always like accusations. The scientific review committee mentions something called the "'guilty complex'-an individual attribute that may lead innocent people to respond physiologically as do guilty people." Anyway, I began to squirm and fidget. Probably I began looking guilty.

At the same time, I noticed that Smith's attitude toward me had changed, that he wasn't as friendly as while I was confessing. The review committee notes that "an examiner's belief, or expectancy, about examinees' guilt or innocence ... may cause the examiner to behave differentially-for instance, in a more hostile manner-toward examinees believed to be guilty or deceptive. Such behavior would plausibly create differential emotional reactions in examinees that could affect physiological responses that are detected by the polygraph."

We want to hear what you think about this article. Submit a letter to the editor or write to letters@theatlantic.com.