He captures my morning-after take exactly:

My completely impressionistic take on Palin's performance tonight is that it mirrored her campaign performance so far (if not quite as dramatically): When Palin started off, you thought, "Wow, she seems so fresh--so human and easy to relate to. How can we compete with that?" Then, as the debate wore on, you thought, "Hmm, okay, she still seems human, but not quite what I'm looking for in a vice president." And, by the end, as the vacuous answers piled up, it was more like, "Good God, keep this woman away from the Oval Office." Which is the story of the last month, too.

We want to hear what you think about this article. Submit a letter to the editor or write to letters@theatlantic.com.