I know, I know. There are almost no independent sources in the email. And it flies in the face of a lot of other reporting. But the emailer has been corresponding with me for a while and is in Iraq in the military. Yes, he may well be biased, as all soldiers are, in as much as he wants his mission to succeed. Which is a good thing. But we know so little for sure, and the signs and counter-signs are as complex as they are fluid, so I felt it worthwhile to air it. Surely our goal now must be to see things as clearly as we can. And put all perspectives on the table.

We want to hear what you think about this article. Submit a letter to the editor or write to letters@theatlantic.com.