A blogger responds to this:

So what would be a victory then? Maybe it would be something like weakening terror groups like Al-Qaida so badly that they cannot mount another major attack, and its few surviving elements remain in hiding and on the run. Which is, in fact, exactly what has happened. When Mr. Sullivan states "We have not stymied Islamist terror" I wonder if he would like to point out any attacks like the Cole bombing, Embassy bombings, or 9/11 that have occurred since the war on terror started.

Madrid, London, Bali and all over Iraq. But read the post.

We want to hear what you think about this article. Submit a letter to the editor or write to letters@theatlantic.com.