Warner, McCain and Graham are not budging, apparently, on the president's war crimes bill. And neither are the JAGs. It really is astonishing to see so many in the military openly and uniformly resist their own commander-in-chief. But Bush's stupidity has given them no choice. This is what Power Line calls "the left." Yep: McCain, Warner and Graham are "the left"; so is the military's legal elite:
Brig, Gen. James C. Walker, the top uniformed lawyer for the Marines, said that no civilized country should deny a defendant the right to see the evidence against him and that the United States 'should not be the first.'
Maj. Gen. Scott C. Black, the judge advocate general of the Army, made the same point, and Rear Adm. Bruce E. MacDonald, the judge advocate general of the Navy, said military law provided rules for using classified evidence, whereby a judge could prepare an unclassified version of the evidence to share with the jury and the accused and his lawyer.
Senate Republicans said the proposal to deny the accused the right to see classified evidence was one of the main points of contention remaining between them and the administration.
'It would be unacceptable, legally, in my opinion, to give someone the death penalty in a trial where they never heard the evidence against them,' said Senator Lindsey Graham of South Carolina, who has played a key role in the drafting of alternative legislation as a member of the Armed Services Committee and a military judge. ''Trust us, you’re guilty, we’re going to execute you, but we can’t tell you why'? That's not going to pass muster; that's not necessary.'
Amazing. Inspiring. But the battle has just begun.
We want to hear what you think about this article. Submit a letter to the editor or write to firstname.lastname@example.org.