This makes for an interesting story from a reader:

"A confession: I lived in this country illegally for the best part of a decade. I came here on a work visa, but the company closed down. I loved New York, and I loved my work. So I started my own company, at one point employing a dozen or so Americans, all of whom paid taxes (as did I, as did the company). I also provided healthcare benefits for my employees and in general, despite my illegal status, made a pretty solid financial contribution to my adopted country.
Eventually, I became legal by paying a small fine (I don't recall how small, but it was 100s, not 1000s of dollars) receiving amnesty and a green card in return. I'm now married to an Amerian woman, still running a business, still paying taxes, and I'd like to think I am a net contributor to this country. People have a stereotype of illegal aliens that makes it easier for them to exercise their bigotry, but the reality is much more diverse and much more complicated."

I wonder how many of those immigrants who flocked to America in the last century and a half were what we now call "legal." I wonder how many managed to came here fraudulently, or quietly across borders, or by over-staying, and turned out to be the backbone of the country. There was a time when anyone who showed up was basically legal. I'm not advocating illegal immigration (and I have tens of thousands of dollars of legal fees to prove it). I am suggesting that it has always been part of this country's history. And it has contributed to the strength and diversity of this country. And it still does.

We want to hear what you think about this article. Submit a letter to the editor or write to