This article is from the archive of our partner .



For the small subset of Americans who still read Archie Comics, there was a big development this week. The publishers introduced Kevin Keller, the franchise's first openly gay character. Debuting in September, the blond-haired, blue-eyed charmer will make a big splash in episode No. 202, titled "Isn't it Bromantic?" The bigger question, however, is how Archie fans will react. To get a sense, we ventured into the obscure world of Archie online fan forums. Here's what we found:

A House Divided  Overall, many devoted fans were supportive of the new character. Frank at Archie Comics Fan Forum for instance:

As always, I support the evolution of Archie in a positive way.  If one young person reads this story and understands that their feelings or the feelings of someone they know are normal then it will have a positive impact.  The truth is that the general readership of Archie deserves a world-view that is inclusive and I, for one, applaud this move.

And others like Tuxedo Mark echoed this sentiment:


As someone whose best friend is gay, I definitely approve of this story. Although, I do admit I was hoping it'd be a female character.

But, as one might expect, dissenters emerged--such as Ralph, a longtime Archie fan weighing in at Animation Magazine:


The majority of the Archie comic audience are kids and sexual orientation has no place in this comic. Archie has been a pillar of honest, genuine content for many successful years so why change that? Create a new comic and have all the gay people you want if that's your thing. My young kids have been reading my old Archies for a few years and now I have to explain the gay character or have them stop reading it.

Questions About Execution  Some worried about how the character would affect the comic at large. RiverPhoenixDale writes:


I hope the new character is introduced casually and without fanfare, rather than splashing it on a cover and making an event out of it.  Because it really shouldn't be a big deal in 2010.

Is Jughead Gay?  When publishers announced that Archie Comics was introducing the "first openly gay character"--not simply "the first gay character"--fans started wondering if some current characters were in the closet. For Sabrina Brody at The Examiner, this was a no-brainer:


Obviously Jughead, that woman hating anti-social with the dry sass, has always been the main gay of Riverdale High.

But others vehemently disagreed. Captain Hero writes:


I know some people keep trying to "out" Jughead...but I think Jughead's more asexual, if anything.

Just another day in Riverdale High ...

This article is from the archive of our partner The Wire.

We want to hear what you think about this article. Submit a letter to the editor or write to letters@theatlantic.com.