Entrepreneurship is a bit like white blood cells. It's a good thing, of course, and something we need. But more of it isn't necessarily good news. It fact, heightened levels of it can be a sign that something is wrong.
Take New Orleans, for example, where per capita start-ups have shot up since Katrina. A resurgent economy needs younger talent, but this is also a sign of a broken city with more cultural appeal than business opportunities, which has forced new residents to start their own companies rather than join existing, thriving enterprises.
In the U.S., start-up-rates perked up after the recession (see chart at the top) and then fallen fast. National media made something of a fetish of entrepreneurs, since this uptick corresponded with a ostensible golden age in Silicon Valley start ups. But many of them were reluctant entrepreneurs, or last-resort entrepreneurs. They weren't starting a company just because they had a great idea. They were starting a "company" because it was an alternative to fruitlessly emailing human resources departments all afternoon.
"It's likely not a coincidence that the number of new businesses created dropped when the economy improved last year," said Dane Stangler, director of research at the Kauffman Foundation. "While a stronger economy is good for business growth, it also means the unemployed find jobs instead of starting firms."
This isn't a new trend. A historical study out of the University of California and RAND found that higher local unemployment rates consistently predicted higher rates of start-ups -- especially sole proprietorships and other firms that never grew beyond one person.
The sort of start-ups that an economy wants -- and that people like Steve Case rightly praise -- are the kind with ramp-up potential. With multinational corporations mostly expanding their hiring abroad, the burden falls to fast-growing start-ups in competitive sectors to support local job creation. In the data, an out-of-work dad who starts a one-man-operation to sell his welding skills might look as entrepreneurial as two in-demand software engineers with huge potential to scale their smartphone app. We want less of the first, more of the second.
We want to hear what you think about this article. Submit a letter to the editor or write to firstname.lastname@example.org.