Stapling Green Cards to Diplomas: Time to Make This Cliche a Law

If you think science matters, or that tech is the future, or that engineers are scarce, you should be furious with the way we treat the world's brightest immigrants

615 brin google.png
Sergey Brin wasn't born in the U.S., but the company he founded, Google, has created tens of thousands of jobs, delighted hundreds of millions of people, and made hundreds of billions of dollars (Reuters)

Last week, President Obama announced that his administration would lift the threat of deportation from more than 800,000 illegal immigrants who arrived in the United States as children and who have gone on to be productive and law-abiding residents. It was good and compassionate public policy -- even if it's a legal stretch.

But more sweeping reform is needed. The United States must stop sending away thousands of foreigners who earn advanced degrees at our universities each year and who want to stay and contribute to our economy.

The fact is that immigrant students capture an incredible share of our science, technology, engineering, and mathematics (STEM) degrees. According to the National Science Foundation, foreigners earned over 13,000 doctorates in science and engineering in 2009 -- nearly one-third of the doctorates granted that year in that category. Foreigners earned more than half the doctorates awarded in every engineering field, computer science, physics, and economics. The story is the same for Master's degrees. Over one-quarter of Master's degrees awarded in 2009 went to foreigners -- 36,000 -- with foreigners accounting for well over one-third of degrees in many STEM fields.

Our annual guide to the modest ideas that can change the world See full coverage

These numbers highlight two encouraging facts. The first is that the world's smartest immigrants want to learn here. We have the finest system of higher education in the world, and young people across the globe work hard for admission to a graduate program at an American university. The second is that every year we have thousands and thousands of newly-minted graduate-degree holders born overseas who can contribute to the American economy by starting businesses, creating jobs, making discoveries, and paying taxes.

Unfortunately, instead of showing those graduates their new offices and bright futures, current immigration policy shows them the door.


When their student visas expire, foreigners have to go through an onerous process to receive the right to work in the United States. Only a certain number of foreigners are granted work visas each year, and many foreigners who graduate from U.S. universities and want to stay and work in the U.S. cannot.

Research by the Technology Policy Institute finds that over 25,000 of these graduates would stay in the United States every year if they weren't forced out. That's not a very big number compared to the president's 800,000, or compared to the approximately one million immigrants in recent years who become legal permanent residents each year. We are hurting the American economy by sending off these talented graduates.

In a National Chamber Foundation report, my AEI colleague Nick Shulz cites research finding that skilled immigrants are 30 percent more likely to start a business than U.S. natives. Among other reasons, this is important because it is new businesses which disproportionately create jobs. One-quarter of STEM-related U.S. businesses founded between 1995 and 2005 were founded by an immigrant. Heard of Google? It was co-founded by a foreign-born Stanford Ph.D. student.

As a country, we share in the costs of educating these foreigners. But just when they can become productive members of society -- starting businesses, creating jobs, inventing new technologies and medicines, and paying taxes -- we tell them to leave. Against their wishes, we tell them to take their skills and talents and ambition to help grow another country's economy


In a hopeful sign, a number of bills to stop the madness have been introduced in Congress, some with bipartisan support. Unfortunately, none of the bills have been voted out of committee.

Both presidential candidates support changing this policy. According to his campaign webpage, Governor Romney supports granting permanent residency to eligible graduates with advanced degrees in STEM fields. President Obama also supports similar legislation, though he hasn't acted on it in his first term.

Others agree. The National Research Council listed giving permanent residency to foreigners who earn doctorates from U.S. universities as one of the top ten policies needed to keep the United States prosperous in the 21st century. Major American corporations like Microsoft support these bills. Major universities do as well.

Foreign graduate students embody the American dream. They have overcome obstacles, gained admission to a university in a faraway country, worked hard to earn their graduate degree, often had to learn a new language and a new culture, and they want to contribute to the country that made their educational dreams come true. Except that many of them can't -- our immigration policy forces them to return home.

In a nod to the DREAM Act, the president is allowing some young illegal immigrants to stay in the United States for the next couple years, free from the threat of deportation. This is a good move. But we can't stop here. The president and Congress are giving the American economy a self-inflicted wound by exporting foreign students who have earned graduate degrees from U.S. universities and who want to stay here and work. These foreigners have dreams, too. The United States should help their dreams become reality.

Read more in our campaign to keep the world's geniuses in the U.S: