The service sector of the economy is growing -- barely -- in the most recent evidence that the economy is U-turning, even though the employment rate is still inching higher. More troubling is the fact that the service sector's recent growth comes on the back of incentives like Cash for Clunkers that have expired. It's a recovery, yes, but it's fragile and jobless and sad.


Bloomberg reports:

Federal Reserve efforts to unlock credit and government measures such as "cash-for-clunkers" and a tax credit for first-time homebuyers are reviving demand and likely helped the economy grow last quarter. Nonetheless, last week's report showing job cuts accelerated in September is a reminder that gains in purchases may not be sustained as incentives expire.

The Federal Reserve is already looking to cut back on its mortgage-backed securities purchases and other credit programs; the first-time home buyers tax credit expires in November; and Cash for Clunkers was a two-week stimulus whose impact on the car market is still being sorted through. The BBC adds that an employer survey found many saying they wouldn't look to rehire until January. So yeah, it's pretty much the worst recovery ever. This is exactly why Congress should extend unemployment benefits, and not just for some states.

We want to hear what you think about this article. Submit a letter to the editor or write to letters@theatlantic.com.