So I saw Dark Knight yesterday, having browbeaten a critic friend into taking me along as his "plus one". The film had slight structural problems, notably a somewhat anticlimactic ending that after an explosive middle, which made it feel a tad long. But overall, it was pretty damn great.

And what about Heath Ledger? I went in prepared to be cynical, since he's probably going to get an Oscar nomination for his role even if he was awful. And . . . he was good. Really good. Not what I would think of as an Oscar quality performance, if for no other reason than that they don't really award Oscars to summer action movies. But I wouldn't be indignant if he walked away with it.

The only movie I've ever seen him in was "10 Things I Hate About You" (yes, yes, I've never seen Brokeback Mountain). I mostly knew him for being extremely pretty. So I was surprised to see him be so good in an adult movie. And if he gets the Oscar, it would be a kind of justice, because his performance suggested that, but for an unlucky combination of pills and alcohol, he might have won one down the road.

We want to hear what you think about this article. Submit a letter to the editor or write to letters@theatlantic.com.