What Beauty Looks Like, From Argentina to Vietnam

By Megan Garber

It started with a self-portrait. Esther Honig sent a photograph of herself, lit simply and shot from the shoulders up, to a designer in Sri Lanka. She sent a simple request along with the photo: "Make me look beautiful."

Honig is a journalist and social media manager based in Kansas City, Missouri; in her work, she'd come across the international freelancing site Fiverr, and noticed how many people on the service were advertising their skills in Photoshop. She got an idea: What would happen if she asked designers from different countries to manipulate her photo—with nothing but a request to "make her look beautiful"?

Honig did just that, asking a group of some 40 designers to Photoshop her into their own idea of beauty. (As a response to anyone confused by her request, Honig would ask the designer to make her look "like a woman in one of their country's fashion magazines.") The results of this exchange are collected in Honig's project Before & Afterwhich offers a revealing, if not at all scientific, insight into various countries' and cultures' assumptions of beauty. There's a lot of lightened skin. And lightened eyes. And heightened hair. Some images give Honig some clothes. One gives her a tattoo.

I asked Honig whether any of the global Photoshops particularly surprised or impressed her. She replied: 

Morocco was the most surprising image, the way the concept of "make me beautiful" was interpreted in this instance left me breathless. In turn the image I received from the U.S. (blond hair) made me shriek, it's been manipulated so radically that it was like looking in the mirror to see a warped image of my own face.

Here's the original, untouched image of Honig:

And here are the results of the Photoshopping, country by country. 

Argentina:

Australia: 

Bangladesh

Bulgaria

Chile

Germany: 

Greece: 

India: 

Indonesia: 

Italy: 

Kenya: 

Morocco: 

Pakistan: 

Philippines: 

Romania: 

Serbia: 

Sri Lanka: 

Ukraine:

United Kingdom:

United States (1): 

United States (2):

Venezuela: 

Vietnam: 

 

This article available online at:

http://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2014/06/what-beauty-looks-like-from-argentina-to-vietnam/373528/