Netbooks Versus the iPad for Work Travel

By Alexis C. Madrigal

Q: I travel a lot for work and I'm tired of lugging a big laptop around. What should I buy, an iPad or a netbook?

A: Not to turn the question around on you, but the real question is: do you need what we've traditionally called a computer? Back in 1982, when people were just beginning to tentatively invite them into their homes, James Fallows began his description of "Living With a Computer" like this, "When I sit down to write a letter or start the first draft of an article, I simply type on the keyboard and the words appear on the screen."

The ability to use a keyboard to write and edit is perhaps the most fundamental part of computerness. Despite all the various attempts to unseat the keyboard, it has proven remarkably resilient, because computers are still largely vehicles for the written word, and half that battle is writing and editing. No other input device does that nearly as well as the keyboard. Sure, you could get an external keyboard and carry that around. But then you lose the glorious sleekness and portability that defines the iPad. At that point, maybe you should just get a netbook.

When I travel, I've been using a little Samsung N310 for a few months and I love it. It's about the size and weight of a hardback book and it can do nearly everything that I normally do with my Macbook Pro. On the other hand, it's certainly possible that you don't need a computer. If what you need is a browser and entertainment device, you cannot beat the iPad. The experience it provides is unparalleled. Just know that your text editing (not to mention file managing) abilities will fall somewhere between what you can do on your smartphone and your (real) computer.

Tools mentioned in this entry:

More questions? View the complete Toolkit archive.

This article available online at:

http://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2010/09/netbooks-versus-the-ipad-for-work-travel/63223/