The Historical Arguments over the FCC's Broadband Plan


The innkeepers and infrastructure plans of yore offer valuable lessons on how to regulate the web.

The debate over net neutrality -- the idea that the government should require that Internet service providers offer unrestricted and equal access to the web -- has intensified lately. Proponents fear that without government intervention, ISPs will act as ruthless gatekeepers to the web.

The ISPs claim regulation will stifle innovation, and say the FCC is trying to use an outmoded set of regulatory powers. The Economist disagrees, citing the age-old idea of "common carriage":

English common law came to see innkeepers, boatmen, warehouse owners and granary operators as "common carriers": transport trades compelled to serve all comers, and to charge reasonable rates.

Similar rules have been applied to American rail, telegraphs and telephones. The great expense of building rail and other infrastructure meant many regions were served by monopolies, so Congress regulated rates to prevent abuse. Much of America is served by cable monopolies, The Economist argues, and so the FCC's reclassification makes sense.

But consultant and author Larry Downes sees a different history lesson: if we keep our hands off of private business, they will build a better network. The infrastructure for railroads, the banking system, electrification, civil aviation, commercial radio, and telephone and telegraph networks all relied on "complicated and delicate private-public partnerships," Downes writes. Companies hoping to profit provided most of the investment, while governments contributed land grants, rights of way and basic research.

The FCC's National Broadband Plan is an ambitious one, on par with major American infrastructure projects, Downes says. But the FCC will trip itself up by seeking net neutrality regulations:

[T]he dogged and increasingly desperate pursuit of regulatory authority over broadband practices will diminish if not poison the investment climate for precisely the kinds of high-risk expenditures necessary to achieve the NBP's goals. Already, Wall Street has responded to the FCC's proposed land-grab by downgrading the stocks of publically-traded ISPs. That comes as a surprise only to consumer advocates who, presumably, have never managed a public company of any size.

Public-private partnerships can create monopolies, Downes concedes. But, as was the case with American rail, the regulations brought problems of their own. The few "isolated incidents" of ISP's offering restricted access "hardly rises to the level of discrimination that justified" the railroad regulations, he argues.

After reading Downes' piece, TechDirt's Mike Masnick concludes that there is no clear answer. The debate is too focused on net neutrality on not enough on competition and the FCC misses the point. It seeks to increase broadband adoption, but it's already widely available, he writes. "It's just that there are lots of people who don't want it yet."

Jump to comments
Presented by

Niraj Chokshi is a former staff editor at, where he wrote about technology. He is currently freelancing and can be reached through his personal website, More

Niraj previously reported on the business of the nation's largest law firms for The Recorder, a San Francisco legal newspaper. He has also been published in The Hartford Courant, The Seattle Times and The Age, in Melbourne, Australia. He's also a longtime programmer and sometimes website designer.
Get Today's Top Stories in Your Inbox (preview)

Why Are Americans So Bad at Saving Money?

The US is particularly miserable at putting aside money for the future. Should we blame our paychecks or our psychology?

Elsewhere on the web

Join the Discussion

After you comment, click Post. If you’re not already logged in you will be asked to log in or register. blog comments powered by Disqus


The Death of Film

You'll never hear the whirring sound of a projector again.


How to Hunt With Poison Darts

A Borneo hunter explains one of his tribe's oldest customs: the art of the blowpipe


A Delightful, Pixar-Inspired Cartoon

An action figure and his reluctant sidekick trek across a kitchen in search of treasure.


I Am an Undocumented Immigrant

"I look like a typical young American."


Why Did I Study Physics?

Using hand-drawn cartoons to explain an academic passion



More in Technology

Just In