Another Texan for President?
By Joshua Green
As he prepares to enter the Republican field, Rick Perry's appeal is clear. So is his one glaring weakness.
HOUSTON -- There's a debate in Texas over whether or not
Governor Rick Perry's prayer rally before 30,000 worshippers in a
football stadium last Saturday was conceived to help launch his
presidential candidacy. But there's little dispute about his prospects
should he decide to enter the Republican field, as expected.
Most people here think he'll win.
Perry's
appeal to Republicans is not hard to fathom. It has three distinct
parts. The first, as the prayer rally demonstrates, is an overt
religiosity that is sure to excite the social conservatives in the
Republican base who feel neglected by the unrelenting focus on the
economy. Perry casts the issue as a crisis of faith. "Lord,'' he told
the crowd, "we see discord at home. We see fear in the marketplace. We
see anger in the halls of government and, as a nation, we have forgotten
who made us, who protects us, who blesses us.'' That message should
resonate across the South and in states like Iowa, where religious
conservatives dominate the party.
Perry's
second strength is his big appeal to the Tea Party movement. Long
before most politicians grasped its significance, he had made himself an
ally. In truth, his populist West Texas conservatism with its native
distrust of Washington prefigured much of what the Tea Party has come to
stand for. Perry has strengthened the connection by adopting the
constitutional fetishism that is a hallmark of the movement. In his new
book, "Fed Up! Our Fight to Save America from Washington,'' he says he'd
like to repeal the 16th and 17th Amendments; his fixation on the 10th
Amendment is already legendary. Though often ridiculed for suggesting,
in 2009, that federal oppression might cause Texas to secede from the
United States, that sentiment helped him shore up conservative support
and come from behind to trounce his 2010 primary opponent, the popular
Senator Kay Bailey Hutchinson.
What
distinguishes him from Michele Bachmann and other Tea Party favorites
is his record of governance, which constitutes the third part of his
appeal. Bachmann says much that excites right-wing conservatives, but
her record is laughably thin. Perry is the nation's longest-serving
governor, of a big state that, relative to everywhere else, is doing
pretty well. A study by the Dallas Federal Reserve found that 37 percent
of all jobs created nationwide since mid-2009 were in Texas. (Although
the state also has considerable poverty and the highest rate of
uninsured residents in the country.) When not leading prayer rallies,
Perry is most eager to tout this aspect of his governorship, and will
base candidacy on the claim that he can do the same from the White
House.
Perry's liabilities
are also plain to see. If scientists set out to build the perfect GOP
candidate, the first thing they'd rule out is making him a Texas
governor. And Perry's brand of conservatism is more brash, divisive, and
extreme than that of his predecessor, George W. Bush. On Saturday, one
of the pastors at his prayer rally characterized him as "Bush on
steroids.''
Rather than try
to mask or downplay what could be a deadly liability, Perry chooses to
embrace it. As Hendrik Hertzberg of The New Yorker has pointed out,
"Perry wears more cowboy gear than a 6-year-old boy on Halloween.'' Even
Republicans inclined to overlook the obvious similarities with Bush
might be deterred by the knowledge that voters in a general election
likely would not.
But in the
short term, Perry's unapologetic embrace of a confrontational
right-wing conservatism should serve him well. In almost every
particular, it will stand him in vivid contrast to the cautious,
considerably more malleable conservatism of the current front-runner,
Mitt Romney. Perry is as temperamentally well-suited to the current
political moment as anyone in the race, and maybe in the country. That's
a big reason why Washington insiders already regard him as the greatest
threat to Romney.
Perry
still has a long way to go. He has never run outside Texas. As a
national candidate, he's entirely unproven and will have to establish
himself. He is said to dislike the press corps, and has largely avoided
it in his own state. But he won't escape scrutiny and may not stand up
to it.
On the other hand, the Texas wisdom holds that it is unwise to bet against him: Perry has won every race he's ever run.
Joshua Green writes a weekly column for the Boston Globe.
Image credit: Jonathan Ernst/Reuters
This article available online at:
http://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2011/08/another-texan-for-president/243444/