'It Should Frighten Everyone in Leadership'

What does Eric Cantor's defeat mean for House Republicans?
Jonathan Ernst/Reuters

Eric Cantor is gone, and if they're not careful, John Boehner and Kevin McCarthy could be next.

The earth-shattering upset in Virginia's 7th District Tuesday night means that Cantor, the House majority leader who has long been considered the heir-apparent to Boehner as speaker, won't be back in the next Congress.

And his loss is a significant victory for a growing group of frustrated House Republicans who have been plotting to shake up the GOP leadership structure ahead of the 114th Congress. Those plans have centered on ejecting Boehner from the speakership and then hoping for a consensus candidate to emerge who could either challenge Cantor for the top job, or at least slide in behind him as majority leader.

But Tuesday night's shocker turns those plans upside down. Cantor's loss not only means there will be a vacant spot in leadership, it also invites more dramatic action from that clutch of conservatives who have grown increasingly disenchanted with a leadership team that they view as out of touch—demographically, ideologically, and strategically—with the membership of the House Republican Conference.

Those conservatives, suddenly smelling blood in the water, might now be emboldened to push for a wholesale change in leadership—ousting Boehner and McCarthy in this November's conference elections, and entering the next Congress with a new top three.

"It should frighten everyone in leadership," one conservative House Republican, who exchanged text messages on condition of anonymity, said shortly after Cantor's defeat was official. "They haven't been conservative enough. We've told them that for 3 years. They wouldn't listen."

The GOP lawmaker added: "Maybe they will listen now."

Indeed, if Cantor's defeat offers a silver lining for Boehner and McCarthy, it's that they now have a five-month audition to convince those conservative members that they won't be ignored any longer. Boehner's fate may already be sealed, as earlier this year National Journal reported that between 40 and 50 members have verbally committed to electing a new speaker. But McCarthy, who is perhaps the most personally popular member of the leadership team, may have an outside shot of retaining his job as majority whip. (He may not want it now that Cantor, his best friend in Congress, has been fired.)

Asked whether Cantor's defeat means he and his fellow conservatives will attempt to clean house and bring in an entirely new leadership team, the House Republican answered: "Not necessarily. The policies are what count. Not the people."

It's a nice sentiment, but Washington is driven by relationships, and the group of young conservatives whose energy has dictated the mood within the House GOP since 2010 is likely to determine who holds the key leadership posts in 2015. The most ubiquitous name is that of Jeb Hensarling, the Texan and Financial Services chairman who conservatives have spent the past several months trying to convince to challenge either Boehner or Cantor. Hensarling has denied interest in doing so, but Cantor's loss will only energize the recruitment efforts.

Another lawmaker worth watching is Representative Tom Price, who is set to succeed Representative Paul Ryan as chairman of the Budget Committee. Price's allies have long argued that the ambitious lawmaker will be satisfied with his chairmanship next year and won't throw away that opportunity to run for a leadership post; that thinking could change very quickly in the weeks ahead.

And, of course, there's Ryan himself, who has long denied interest in the speakership—likely to avoid conflict with his friend Cantor—but who now enjoys a wide-open path to the speaker's office.

Still, there's no question that policy is important, and, indeed, the policies coming from the majority leader's office have been increasingly problematic for some conservatives. Cantor has been emphatic in conversations with colleagues that he wants to pass serious immigration reform, especially something that helps young illegal immigrants who were brought here by their parents— or, as Cantor calls them, "the kids." This image of Cantor as soft on immigration has hardened in recent months, prompting David Brat, his primary challenger, to attack the majority leader for supporting "amnesty."

If the immigration talk wasn't enough to rankle some of the conference's most conservative members, Cantor made more enemies by muscling a flood-insurance bill through the House earlier this year, over the objections of many Republicans, including Hensarling, whose Financial Services Committee has jurisdiction over the matter. (Some members saw Cantor's actions as deliberately intended to weaken Hensarling, who has emerged as the consensus choice of conservatives looking to vault one of their own into the uppermost echelons of leadership.)

Presented by

Tim Alberta is editor of Hotline Last Call!, the afternoon newsletter of National Journal Hotline.

The Best 71-Second Animation You'll Watch Today

A rock monster tries to save a village from destruction.

Join the Discussion

After you comment, click Post. If you’re not already logged in you will be asked to log in or register.

blog comments powered by Disqus


The Best 71-Second Animation You'll Watch Today

A rock monster tries to save a village from destruction.


The Case for Napping at Work

Most Americans don't get enough sleep. More and more employers are trying to help address that.


A Four-Dimensional Tour of Boston

In this groundbreaking video, time moves at multiple speeds within a single frame.


Who Made Pop Music So Repetitive? You Did.

If pop music is too homogenous, that's because listeners want it that way.


Stunning GoPro Footage of a Wildfire

In the field with America’s elite Native American firefighting crew

More in Politics

Just In