Our Terrible, Horrible, No Good, Very Bad Congress

Tea Party backed GOP members are boasting that they were able to stop Democrats from spending more. Senate Democrats claim they tried to pass important legislation but were stymied by Republicans.

This stalemate will undoubtedly continue at least through the election and push any substantive action to the end of the year -- or possibly into 2013.

* * *

In the lame duck session after the election, Congress will have to deal with the "fiscal cliff" -- the automatic federal spending cuts and expiration of tax reduction programs all scheduled to hit on Jan. 1. The Bush tax cuts and many other tax provisions expire at the end of the year. The Senate has passed legislation to continue the reductions for those making less than $250,000 and the House has passed a one-year extension of all of the cuts.

Since no federal budget has been approved, the government runs out of money at the start of the fiscal year on Oct. 1. Congressional leaders have reached a tentative agreement to fund the government for an additional six months but that deal still has to be approved by the members of the House and Senate.

Conservative GOP House freshmen might be expected to balk at the deal except that Republicans probably don't want to take the chance of reminding people about the disastrous government shutdown of 1995 for which they were blamed.

The government may not be forced to grind to a halt but the Pentagon and federal agencies don't know how much money they will have to spend or if they will need to lay off federal workers thanks to "sequestration," mandatory cuts to federal programs authorized by bipartisan House and Senate votes last year.

When members of the "Supercommittee" couldn't agree last fall on how to deal with the nation's debt and deficit, Congress approved a sudden-death mechanism that triggers $100 billion in automatic budget cuts split between defense and non-defense programs. The reductions will take effect Jan. 1, 2013 unless the two parties can agree on a plan to reduce the $1 trillion deficit by the end of the year or find a way -- to use Washington's favorite metaphor -- to kick the can down the road.

Privately, some Democrats say maybe they should just let the sequestration cuts happen so that Americans can feel the pain of such severe federal budget cuts. And some Republicans are saying if the Democrats won't agree to extend tax cuts for the wealthy -- let all of the Bush tax cuts expire to force their hand. But this game of chicken with the U.S. economy is not only childish, it has the potential to have dire consequences at a time when the economy and the American people can't stand much more.

A just released Congressional Budget Office report predicts that a combination of deep federal spending cuts and a tax increase would trigger another recession and a nine percent unemployment rate. Even now, many economists say the uncertainty about how, or if, Congress will deal with these issues is having a negative impact on business decisions.

Republicans, worried about the planned defense cuts, are threatening to shift all of the reductions to entitlement programs -- a strategy that would never get through the Democratic controlled Senate. And defense contractors and lobbyists are gearing up to swarm the Capitol in September, pressuring members of both parties to prevent the cuts. There have been bipartisan groups in both the House and Senate championing efforts to deal with the nation's budget and fiscal problems with a mixture of revenue increases, entitlement reform and spending cuts and using the Simpson-Bowles deficit reduction plan as a model. But so far they haven't gotten much traction.

Democratic Senator Mark Warner of Virginia has worked for two years with a group originally called the Gang of Six to try to work out a deficit reduction plan based on Simpson-Bowles.

"I'm really hoping that reasonable people in both parties will say 'no mas'. If we don't get it fixed we all ought to get fired. Politics is the only business I've ever seen where people can make a whole career out of just being against stuff," said Warner. "Acting irresponsibly has become the norm."

Mitt Romney's selection of House Budget Chairman Paul Ryan, who advocates deficit reduction through deep spending cuts in domestic programs, Medicare and other entitlements, but no new revenue, has insured that this issue will be part of the election discussion.

Ryan and Tom Coburn were both members of the Simpson-Bowles deficit commission. But while Ryan voted against it, Coburn, who is also a member of the Gang of Six, voted in favor of the final commission report. "Let's have the fight about the solutions but let's quit lying about the problems. We need some people with guts in Washington willing to do what's right," Coburn insisted.

Like most Democrats, Udall believes you can't deal with the debt unless you discuss revenue as well as spending: "Until the Tea Party element decides they really want the country to move forward...we're going to be challenged. They think if you cut taxes and end the federal government everything is going to be hunky dory."

Rep. Barney Frank, D-Mass, agreed with that assessment. "This is the most radical group and they have the rest of the Republican Party terrified...they're extremists," he said. At 72, Frank has decided he's also leaving Congress at the end of this year. Always blunt-spoken, he's become more critical of the hyper-partisan atmosphere as his departure date approaches.

"I think it's a misconception to say it's the freshmen that are causing the problem," said Rep. Charlie Bass, a New Hampshire Republican. "There is a group of very conservative people in our caucus that are holding things up, but it's not just the freshmen."

Bass supported the Simpson Bowles plan and is part of a small House group led by Ohio Republican Steve LaTourette and Democrat Jim Cooper that is pushing for a similar debt reduction approach that includes revenue increases, spending cuts and entitlement reform.

LaTourette, who has served in the House since 1994 and is one of a few remaining moderate Republicans, abruptly announced at the end of July that he is also leaving Congress, saying he's had enough of the partisanship, polarization and inability to get things done. LaTourette told Roll Call that compromise has become "a dirty word."

Everything has become about politics, said Coburn. "The election has been going on now for 18 months and it's sickening." Coburn was reelected to his second Senate term in 2010 but says he won't seek another.

Ritchie, the Senate historian, said it's wrong to blame the institution of Congress, when the political parties are the problem: "We are the most polarized we've been in 100 years -- but it's the parties. You can't expect a productive Congress if one party is in charge of the House and another in charge of the Senate. It's two equal bodies that frustrate each other constantly and it's a recipe for gridlock."

Sen. Snowe believes the ultimate power for fixing things rests with the voters. "The American people are going to have to think about whom they're voting for and reward those politicians willing to work together and penalize those who don't," she predicted.

But she's not optimistic that will happen before she leaves the Senate.

Presented by

Linda Killian is a Washington journalist and a senior scholar at the Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars. Her book The Swing Vote: The Untapped Power of Independents was published in January 2012 by St. Martin's Press.

Join the Discussion

After you comment, click Post. If you’re not already logged in you will be asked to log in or register with Disqus.

Please note that The Atlantic's account system is separate from our commenting system. To log in or register with The Atlantic, use the Sign In button at the top of every page.

blog comments powered by Disqus


A Stop-Motion Tour of New York City

A filmmaker animated hundreds of still photographs to create this Big Apple flip book


The Absurd Psychology of Restaurant Menus

Would people eat healthier if celery was called "cool celery?"


This Japanese Inn Has Been Open for 1,300 Years

It's one of the oldest family businesses in the world.


What Happens Inside a Dying Mind?

Science cannot fully explain near-death experiences.

More in Politics

Just In