Occupy Wall Street and the Return of Law and Order Politics

As city after city confronts Occupy protestors, conservatives are trying to make civil unrest into an anti-Obama campaign issue


As Occupiers from Oakland and Atlanta to New York City and Washington, D.C., have proven themselves both too powerless to prevent the encroachment of crime in their encampments and powerful enough to repeatedly confront police, the president's fiercest critics on the right are uniting around a potentially powerful new election-year theme: Barack Obama can't preserve law and order.

Critics of the conservative media have long complained of a perpetual outrage machine that says anything to see Democrats suffer at the polls. But today, they should take a careful look at the way the Occupy movement is helping to pipe the law-and-order message of the conservative counter-establishment back into the heart of the mainstream GOP.

Rather than the triumph of the lunatic fringe or a regression to some paranoid mean, the move marks a return of a core issue for the modern Republican Party. Republicans are justified in expecting electoral success when Americans worry about the government's ability (and willingness) to prevent, control, and punish social unrest.

Amid a growing chorus of conservative criticism, New York City Mayor Michael Bloomberg chose on November 15th to demonstrate that ability. At one o'clock in the morning, the NYPD told the Occupiers at Zuccotti Park to immediately remove all tents, sleeping bags, and belongings from the campsite -- that is, to turn Zuccotti from a campsite back into a park. "Many protesters," Bloomberg explained in the press conference that followed, "peacefully complied and left." With sanitation crews in tow, police "assisted in removing any remaining tents and sleeping bags," arresting dozens in the process. Urging his audience to "make no mistake -- the final decision was mine," Bloomberg justified the crackdown explicitly in terms of law and order: "We must never be afraid to insist on compliance with our laws," he said. "The First Amendment gives every New Yorker the right to speak out -- but it does not give anyone the right to sleep in a park or otherwise take it over to the exclusion of others -- nor does it permit anyone in our society to live outside the law."

Bloomberg recognized that local pressure was reaching a tipping point, from business and government to popular sentiment. But his abrupt response perhaps also reflects the uncomfortable national exposure trained on him by the conservative media. Bloomberg's response to Zuccotti -- or lack thereof -- had become the ongoing news hook for right-of-center stories and editorials lambasting failed government as hallmark of the Obama era. The mayor's inaction swiftly sped the anti-Occupy meme up the ladder of the conservative media. In the predawn hours of November 1st, Andrew Breitbart became the first to bring grassroots conservative disgust over reports of violence at Occupy camps before the big conservative media. "Rapes, Gropes, and Assaults, Oh My," read the headline of his post. "Mayor Bloomberg, Shut Down Zuccotti Park!" Accompanied by the first of several videos obtained from an activist conducting dismaying interviews on location, Breitbart demanded that Bloomberg stop "allowing New York's inmates to run the asylum" -- a "bad example that is being repeated across the country, with dozens of known victims."

On November 3rd, the New York Post followed suit, running its own editorial announcing it was "Time to throw the bums out:"

If they choose not to leave -- which they probably won't -- then Bloomberg needs to instruct the NYPD to clean the mess up. Today wouldn't be a day too soon.

Only two days later, the editors of National Review put the stamp of the conservative establishment's approval on the ultimatum: "Mr. Mayor, Tear Down Those Tents." And if Bloomberg himself wouldn't do it, well, "[i]t matters not who makes the first move, so long as the last move is the striking of the tents along Trotsky Alley."

Notably, the blame for the mess at Zuccotti broadened the closer the story got to the center of Republican power -- and in only a matter of days. Breitbart took the relatively narrow approach of using direct, unmediated video interviews with dismayed Occupiers themselves to advocate an end to Bloomberg's lenience, which functioned, he argued, as a model of governmental negligence that "set the stage" for "patterns" of "chaos and crime" across America.

Expanding the critique, the New York Post opined that "[w]hat began as a credible protest against bank bailouts, crony capitalism and the like has, in large measure, been hijacked by crazies and criminals." Bloomberg needed to stand "firm in the face of the firestorm that surely will ignite" when the "party" was finally "over" -- a firestorm, to be sure, of proportions as national as the new issue that Occupy had unleashed: not the corrupt relationship between big finance and big government, but the questionable relationship between the perpetrators of public disorder and the out-of-towners -- "radicals" and "manipulators in the labor unions seeking to capitalize on the 'occupation.'"

By the time National Review had thought things through -- again, in less than a week -- Bloomberg's tolerance was seen as a response to America's "community organizer in chief."

Hoovervilles, the unfortunately named shantytowns that dotted the country during the Depression, were places of desperation. But the tent city (Obamaville?) that has sprung up in Zuccotti Park is something else altogether.

These tent-dwellers, the editorial argued, were remarkably well-fed and well-appointed. A risk-averse Bloomberg may have been the proximate cause of Zuccotti Park's decadence and depravity, the editors said -- but the root cause was now identified as Barack Obama's policies, both active and passive.

Presented by

James Poulos is a columnist at The Daily Caller and a contributor at Ricochet. He is on Twitter at @jamespoulos.

Before Tinder, a Tree

Looking for your soulmate? Write a letter to the "Bridegroom's Oak" in Germany.

Join the Discussion

After you comment, click Post. If you’re not already logged in you will be asked to log in or register.

blog comments powered by Disqus


Before Tinder, a Tree

Looking for your soulmate? Write a letter to the "Bridegroom's Oak" in Germany.


The Health Benefits of Going Outside

People spend too much time indoors. One solution: ecotherapy.


Where High Tech Meets the 1950s

Why did Green Bank, West Virginia, ban wireless signals? For science.


Yes, Quidditch Is Real

How J.K. Rowling's magical sport spread from Hogwarts to college campuses


Would You Live in a Treehouse?

A treehouse can be an ideal office space, vacation rental, and way of reconnecting with your youth.

More in Politics

Just In